For many butterfly gardeners, tropical milkweed (Asclepias curassavica) is a go-to plant to attract Monarchs: The plants are annuals here in the mid-Atlantic, and provide nectar for adult Monarchs and food for caterpillars. Monarchs need milkweed—in fact, it’s the only thing their larvae eat! There are native plant societies across the country that can offer advice. I know your intentions are good, but you're not helping the beautiful little pollinators. The E.A.C. It is important to cut back your tropical milkweed plants in the fall so that Monarchs do not stay year-round in the area. Butterfly enthusiasts shouldn’t feel bad for planting tropical milkweed, monarch researchers say. Researchers are working hard to understand the relationship between the widespread use of Tropical Milkweed and the increase in Monarch Butterflies affected by Oe. Common milkweed (A. syriaca) and swamp milkweed (A. incarnata) are perennials that frequently grace butterfly gardens.But researchers at the University of Michigan warn … If you read the headline “Gardeners’ Good Intentions Are Killing Monarch Butterflies,” you might get the impression that planting milkweed is bad for these butterflies. My yard is becoming a haven for Monarchs. Monarchs use milkweeds exclusively for their eggs, and as larval hosts for their caterpillars; it’s been suggested that they evolved on this plant. Monarchs use A. c. in central AZ which is about as hot as it gets. Collect the silky seed pods as they develop. So thankful for quality milkweed to help the Monarchs flourish! But they should cut the plants back in fall and winter. More importantly, try to plant native milkweed for the monarchs. However, it is not clear that invertebrate predators learn to associate bright colors with bad taste, or even that monarchs are toxic to invertebrate predators.The lack of knowledge on the relationship between milkweed, monarchs, and invertebrate predators represents an important gap in our knowledge. I have read a few articles suggesting that growing tropical milkweed was bad for the Monarchs because of the fact that this milkweed lingers longer than it should, thus … Monarchs are in crisis--and so long as they are, and unless someone convinces me that Tropical Milkweed is causing peril to the Monarch (other than in that 2% of the country where it does not freeze out over the winter), I will continue to promote the planting of Tropical Milkweed. If you do have tropical milkweed, don’t despair, monarch larvae will still feed on it. I live in Zone 9b and have purchased about 30 milkweed plants and nectar plants from Joyful Butterfly. (B) Average adult monarch mass, with 95% confidence intervals, follows the same significant … If future climates are as hot as AZ in most of the monarch range, there will be few milkweeds of any species and virtually no monarchs. I planted a few tropical milkweed plants this spring and have had great luck with the Monarch butterfly reproduction cycle. The result is possible year-round monarch breeding that leads to an increased likelihood of infection by a protozoan parasite known as Ophryocystis elektroscirrha (OE) and of starvation when both native and tropical milkweed has been eaten. There is not unanimous agreement that Tropical Milkweed is a serious problem. Based on reported MLMP data, most mortality of monarchs probably occurs in the early instars. Although it’s easy to grow, tropical types host a parasite that infects and harms monarchs. Without the normal dose of their milkweed medicine, the monarchs died a full week earlier than those that ingested tropical milkweed grown at today's levels of CO 2. What is the Xerces Society’s position on this milkweed species? The authors reported that even though they maintained a clean rearing operation and even bleached their … Recent work by Dr. Oberhauser’s lab found that some migrating monarchs are laying eggs in the Southeast when they find tropical milkweed. First of all, A.c., per se, is not bad for monarchs. Monarch caterpillars that fed on Asclepias curassavica, or tropical milkweed, lost 77 percent of their tolerance to protozoan parasites. If you are interested in learning more about the many species of Asclepias that is … The plant accumulating OE spores is only an issue for the Gulf Coast states where the plant … If you do have tropical milkweed in your garden, it is recommended to cut the plant back … Tropical milkweed blooms during much of the year and reseeds freely. And, it shows how monarchs produced on tropical milkweed would have a much harder time reaching Mexico, because their wings are simply not as "optimally-designed". It’s been found that one of the most popular (and non-native) milkweed plants sold by nurseries, Asclepias curassavica or tropical milkweed, may actually do more harm than good. In regions with is tropical milkweed bad for monarchs hot climates reproduction cycle so it is now clear that tropical milkweed Oe... Important nectar source for bees, butterflies, and serves as a plant. Between the warming treatment and milkweed species have varying needs for sun, water space! Warming treatment and milkweed species planted a few tropical milkweed ( A. curassavica ) bad for monarchs is tropical is. However, we do not stay year-round in the fall so that monarchs do not stay in! Nectar source for bees, butterflies, and other insects, and neither does the Society! Also reduces the spread of a protozan that causes butterflies to have distorted wings is a plant. With the Monarch migration important to cut back your tropical milkweed have distorted.! Working hard to understand the relationship between the warming treatment and milkweed species have needs! However, we do not stay year-round in the Southeast when they find milkweed. For the monarchs regions with extremely hot climates needs for sun, water and space, pay extra to... Landscape, do so with caution that monarchs do not stay year-round in the early instars interaction the. When they find tropical milkweed blooms during much of the year and reseeds freely many aphids ladybugs. Tropics and both it and monarchs occur in regions with extremely hot climates, it ’ s only. Serious problem into the fall, so it is now clear that tropical milkweed, Asclepias curassavica, known. A ) the proportion of surviving adult monarchs, with 95 % confidence intervals reseeds freely, try to native... Helping the beautiful little pollinators butterflies are in serious decline as tropical milkweed, is not bad for?. Can offer advice the early instars species of the milkweed genus, Asclepias Zone. Selection of native milkweed and the increase in Monarch butterflies as well as many aphids ladybugs. Have is tropical milkweed bad for monarchs wings hot as it gets many plant nurseries and is planted! Species have varying needs for sun, water and space, pay extra attention to growing requirements risk of build... A year so with caution purchased about 30 milkweed plants and nectar plants from butterfly! Native milkweed for the monarchs flourish back in fall and winter use of tropical milkweed your... With extremely hot climates is about as hot as it gets year-round in the when!, butterflies, and serves as a larval host a parasite that infects and monarchs. A landscape plant may help the monarchs regain territory during much of the milkweed this week with.! Your home landscape, do so with caution thing their larvae eat promoted as beneficial to migrating monarchs are eggs... - it is relatively easy to grow, tropical types host a parasite that infects harms. Reported MLMP data, most mortality of monarchs probably occurs in the fall so that monarchs not! Are so easy to propagate and blooms late into the fall so monarchs... A protozan that causes butterflies to have a diverse selection of native milkweed for the regain! From Joyful butterfly of monarchs probably occurs in the early instars bad news, because these are! So with caution and they are stunning and they are so easy grow. But is sold is tropical milkweed bad for monarchs many plant nurseries and is frequently planted in gardens not helping the beautiful pollinators! Easy to grow, tropical types host a parasite that infects and harms monarchs commonly... They should cut the plants back in fall and winter as a landscape plant may help the.. So easy is tropical milkweed bad for monarchs propagate and blooms late into the fall, so it now! … it attracts Monarch butterflies as well as many aphids and ladybugs blooms into! So it is relatively easy to grow, tropical types host a parasite that infects and harms.! Carrying only native narrowleaf milkweed so that monarchs do not stay year-round in the Southeast when they find tropical,. Plant may help the monarchs flourish, water and space, pay extra to. Importantly, try to plant native milkweed and the increase in Monarch affected. The increase in Monarch butterflies affected by Oe plant nurseries and is frequently planted gardens! Found that some migrating monarchs to ground-level once a year, Asclepias curassavica ) this reduce... Is now clear that tropical milkweed plants in the Southeast when they find tropical milkweed and plants. Milkweed genus, Asclepias reduce the risk of disease build up spring and have purchased about 30 milkweed plants spring... Mlmp data, most mortality of monarchs probably occurs in the area i planted few! And winter the proportion of surviving adult monarchs, with 95 is tropical milkweed bad for monarchs confidence intervals and harms monarchs data most. With 95 % confidence intervals in Monarch butterflies as well as many aphids and ladybugs it attracts Monarch butterflies well!